Solar & Mars Landing
Big ideas

Light speed, time travel and wormholes

by Joe Miller

Who first suggested these ideas, and why? Light travels about 186,000 miles a second, and since Einstein we know nothing with mass can reach it. Going into the future is real physics. Going into the past, and shortcut tunnels through space, are allowed on paper but have never been seen.

Watch: the narrated video (17 minutes)

Take the free test   Practice first

10 questions, every answer explained, printable certificate at 80%. Prefer to listen? Audio only (MP3).

The speed ladderEach step is many times faster than the one below. Light is in a class of its own.Light670 million mphParker Solar Probe, fastest spacecraft430,000 mphEarth, circling the Sun67,000 mphVoyager 1, leaving the solar system38,000 mphApollo, heading to the Moon24,500 mphSpace station17,500 mphRifle bulletabout 1,800 mphAirliner560 mphCar on the highway65 mphBicycle12 mphWalking3 mphBars use a stretched (logarithmic) scale. Light is about 1,500 times faster than our fastest spacecraft, and 220 million times faster than walking.
From walking to light. Light is about 1,500 times faster than our fastest spacecraft, the Parker Solar Probe.
How long light takes to get thereLight travels about 186,000 miles a secondThe Moon1.3 secondsThe Sun8 minutes 20 secondsMars3 to 22 minutesJupiter33 to 53 minutesVoyager 1, our farthest shipabout 1 dayAlpha Centauri, nearest star4.2 yearsBars use a stretched (logarithmic) scale. Voyager 1, at 38,000 mph, goes less than 1/10,000 of light speed.
Light could circle Earth about 7 times in one second, yet the nearest star is still 4.2 light-years away.

Reaching for light speed

WhoWhenThe ideaWhy they suggested it
Konstantin Tsiolkovsky (Russia)1903The rocket equation, and people settling spaceHe believed Earth was humanity's cradle, and people cannot live in the cradle forever
Albert Einstein1905Nothing goes faster than light; time slows for fast travelersHe was making light and motion obey the same rules. The speed limit fell out of the math
Eugen Sänger (Germany)1950sThe photon rocket, pushed by light itselfLight is the fastest possible exhaust, so it makes the most powerful rocket possible
Ted Taylor and Freeman Dyson1958-1968Project Orion: a ship pushed by small nuclear blastsThe only known way to get huge speed from technology that already existed

Reaching for the stars

WhoWhenThe ideaWhy they suggested it
Robert Bussard1960The interstellar ramjet: scoop up hydrogen in space for fuelCarrying all your fuel to the stars is impossible, so collect it on the way
British Interplanetary Society (Alan Bond)1973-1978Project Daedalus: an uncrewed fusion probe to Barnard's Star in about 50 yearsTo prove a star mission could fit in one human lifetime
Robert Forward1984A light sail pushed by giant lasersLeave the engine and the fuel at home, so the ship can be very light
Yuri Milner and Stephen Hawking2016Breakthrough Starshot: tiny chips on light sails at 20% of light speedTo reach Alpha Centauri in about 20 years, within our lifetimes

Faster than light: the warp drive

WhoWhenThe ideaWhy they suggested it
Star Trek1966Warp drive, on televisionScience fiction needed a way to cross the galaxy in one episode
Miguel Alcubierre (Mexico)1994Shrink space in front of the ship and stretch it behind, so the ship rides a bubbleInspired by Star Trek, he checked whether Einstein's own math allows it. It does, on paper
Harold "Sonny" White (NASA)2011A warp-bubble shape needing far less energyTo see whether a warp effect could ever be tested in a lab

The catch: a warp bubble needs "negative energy," and far more than anyone knows how to make.

The warp drive idea (Alcubierre, 1994)Direction of travelSpace squeezed aheadSpace stretched behindShip rides in a bubbleAllowed by Einstein's equations on paper, but it needs "negative energy," which may not exist in useful amounts.
Space squeezed ahead and stretched behind; the ship rides in a bubble, a bit like standing on a moving walkway.
The warp bubble in 3DAlcubierre's idea: space rises (expands) behind the ship and dips (contracts) ahead of itTravelSpace expands behindSpace contracts aheadThe ship itself never moves faster than light inside its bubble. Making the bubble would need negative energy, which may not exist in useful amounts.
The warp bubble in 3D: space rises behind the ship and dips ahead of it, and the ship rides the wave.

Time travel

Time travel: Einstein, a clock and swirling space
Einstein showed that time is not the same for everyone. That opened the door to time travel, and to its paradoxes.

Time travel into the future

WhoWhenThe ideaWhy they suggested it
H. G. Wells1895The Time Machine: time as a fourth dimension you can travel throughA novel, partly to warn where society could end up. It made time travel famous
Albert Einstein1905Move fast and less time passes for youIt came from the same speed-of-light rules. It is real travel into the future
Paul Langevin (France)1911The twin paradox: one twin flies to a star and comes home youngerTo make Einstein's idea easy to picture
Joseph Hafele and Richard Keating1971Flew atomic clocks around the world on airlinersTo test Einstein. The clocks disagreed by billionths of a second, just as predicted
The twin paradox: a real trip into the futureEarthAlpha Centauri4.2 light-yearsOut and back at 99% of light speedTwin who stays homeAges about 8.7 yearsTwin who travelsAges only about 1.2 yearsEinstein, 1905; Langevin's twins, 1911. Measured with atomic clocks on airliners in 1971.
Out and back to Alpha Centauri at 99% of light speed: the traveling twin comes home about 7½ years younger.

Time travel into the past

WhoWhenThe ideaWhy they suggested it
Kurt Gödel1949A spinning universe where you could loop back into your own pastA birthday gift to his friend Einstein, arguing time may not really "flow"
Kip Thorne and Michael Morris1988A wormhole people could pass through, which could become a time machineCarl Sagan asked Thorne for realistic science for his novel Contact
J. Richard Gott (Princeton)1991A time machine made from "cosmic strings"To find what the laws of physics allow at the extremes
Stephen Hawking1992Chronology protection: nature forbids trips to the pastTo stop paradoxes, like going back and preventing your own birth
Ronald Mallett (UConn)2000sA time machine using circulating beams of lightHis father died when he was 10, and he dreamed of going back to warn him

Time travel paradoxes

ParadoxThe puzzleWhere it comes from
Grandfather paradoxGo back and stop your grandparents meeting. Then you are never born, so who went back?Made famous by René Barjavel's 1943 novel
Bootstrap paradoxYour future self hands you plans you later carry back. Who invented them? No oneNamed for Robert Heinlein's 1941 story "By His Bootstraps"
Predestination paradoxYou travel back to stop an event, and your trip is what causes itAn old idea, as old as the Greek story of Oedipus
Butterfly effectChange one tiny thing in the past and the whole future comes out differentRay Bradbury's 1952 story "A Sound of Thunder"; Edward Lorenz named it in 1972
Billiard ball paradoxA ball goes through a wormhole, comes out earlier, and knocks itself off courseJoseph Polchinski, about 1990, as a challenge to Kip Thorne
Where are the time travelers?If time travel is ever invented, why haven't visitors from the future shown up?Stephen Hawking's 2009 party
Twin paradox (solved)Each twin sees the other moving. Why does only one age less?Only the traveler turns around and changes speed, so the trips are not equal
The grandfather paradoxGo back and stop your grandparents from meeting... then who traveled back?Time1950: grandparents meetYour birthYou build a time machine1. You travel back2. They never meet3. So you are never born...4. ...so who went back?Made famous by René Barjavel's 1943 novel. It is the classic argument that changing the past may be impossible.
Stop your grandparents from meeting, and you are never born... so who traveled back?
The bootstrap paradoxSomething that loops through time with no beginningTime20202050Your older self brings back the plans for a time machineYou keep them for 30 years, then carry them back yourselfSo who invented the plans? Nobody: they only exist inside the loop. Named for Robert Heinlein's 1941 story "By His Bootstraps."
The plans loop from your older self to your younger self and back. Nobody ever invented them.
Polchinski's billiard ball paradoxA ball rolls into a wormhole, comes out earlier, and knocks its younger self awayMouth A (later)Mouth B (earlier)The ballComes out earlierand hits itselfJoseph Polchinski posed it to Kip Thorne around 1990. In 1991 Thorne's team found that a glancing blow works: the ball isnudged just enough to still enter the wormhole, so history stays consistent.
The ball comes out of the wormhole earlier and hits itself. A glancing blow keeps history consistent.
Where are all the time travelers?Stephen Hawking's party, June 28, 2009, CambridgeYou are cordially invitedto a reception for Time Travellers12:00 UT, 28 June 2009 (sent out afterward)Champagne poured, chairs ready... nobody came.Hawking called it experimental evidence against travel into the past. (Or the future is not interested in us.)
Hawking sent the invitations after the party, so only time travelers could have come. Nobody did.

Three ways out of the paradoxes

AnswerHow it worksWho
One fixed historyYou can visit the past, but whatever you do there already happened. Paradoxes simply cannot occurIgor Novikov, the self-consistency principle, 1980s
A new branchChanging the past starts a separate timeline; your original world is untouchedDavid Deutsch, using quantum physics, 1991
Nature says noPhysics destroys any time machine before it can workStephen Hawking, chronology protection, 1992
Three ways out of the paradoxesOne fixed historyYou can visit the past, but youwere always part of itIgor Novikov, 1980sA new branchThe changed worldYour original worldChanging the past starts aseparate timelineDavid Deutsch, 1991Nature says noBlockedPhysics destroys any timemachine before it worksStephen Hawking, 1992Nobody knows which is right. All three agree you could not erase your own past.
Nobody knows which answer is right, but all three agree you could not erase your own past.
A wormhole: a shortcut through spacePlace APlace BThe long way:light-yearsThe shortcut(the wormhole)Space drawn as a folded sheet. Allowed by Einstein's equations; none has ever been found, and holding one open needs exotic matter.
Picture space as a folded sheet. The long way could be light-years; a wormhole would tunnel straight through.

Wormholes: the early ideas

WhoWhenThe ideaWhy they suggested it
Ludwig Flamm (Austria)1916The math of a black hole can connect to a second region of spaceHe was studying Schwarzschild's new black hole solution; the tunnel appeared by surprise
Albert Einstein and Nathan Rosen1935The Einstein-Rosen bridge, a tunnel joining two placesThey were trying to describe particles like the electron, not travel
John Wheeler (Princeton)1957Named them "wormholes"He pictured a worm eating through an apple: a shortcut instead of going around
Robert Fuller and John Wheeler1962The Einstein-Rosen bridge snaps shut too fast for even light to crossTo test whether the bridge was a real passage. It was not
Homer Ellis and Kirill Bronnikov1973The first wormholes that stay openThey were exploring which shapes of space Einstein's equations allow

Wormholes: the modern ideas

WhoWhenThe ideaWhy they suggested it
Michael Morris and Kip Thorne (Caltech)1988A wormhole people could travel through, held open by "exotic matter"Carl Sagan asked for realistic science for Contact
Matt Visser (New Zealand)1989Wormhole designs needing much less exotic matterTo make wormholes look less impossible
Juan Maldacena and Leonard Susskind2013"ER = EPR": wormholes and quantum entanglement may be the same thingTo solve the puzzle of what happens to information that falls into a black hole
Ping Gao, Daniel Jafferis and Aron Wall2016Quantum effects can briefly hold a wormhole openA version physics might allow. The catch: going through is slower than going around
Google and Caltech team2022Simulated a tiny wormhole on a quantum computerTo study wormhole physics in a lab. A simulation, not a real tunnel

No wormhole has ever been found.

What's real today

Why GPS needs EinsteinEarthGPS satellite, 12,550 miles upMoving fast slows its clock− 7 millionths of a second a dayWeaker gravity speeds it up+ 45 millionths of a second a dayTogether+ 38 millionths of a second a dayWithout the correction, GPS would driftabout 6 miles (10 km) off every day.
Your phone depends on Einstein: GPS satellite clocks are corrected by 38 millionths of a second every day.

GPS needs Einstein

GPS satellite clocks run about 38 millionths of a second a day fast. Without correcting them, GPS would drift miles off every day.

A real time traveler

Cosmonaut Sergei Krikalev spent over 800 days in orbit. Because of his speed, he is about 1/50 of a second in our future.

Negative energy exists

Two metal plates very close together in a vacuum get pushed toward each other: the Casimir effect, measured in 1997. A wormhole would need vastly more.

Movies with real math

Kip Thorne advised Interstellar (2014). Its wormhole near Saturn came from his equations.

Who thought of it, and when

Who thought of it, and whenLight speed1903Tsiolkovsky1905Einstein1960Bussard ramjet1966Star Trek warp1984Forward light sail1994Alcubierre warp2016StarshotTime travel1895H. G. Wells1905Einstein1911Twin paradox1949Gödel1971Clocks on planes1988Thorne1992HawkingWormholes1916Flamm1935Einstein-Rosen1957Wheeler names them1973Ellis, Bronnikov1988Morris-Thorne2013ER = EPR2022Quantum sim190019251950197520002025
More than a century of ideas, from H. G. Wells in 1895 to a wormhole simulated on a quantum computer in 2022.

With known physics, nothing goes faster than light. That is why, for now, the stars are a job for light sails and small, patient, self-copying machines. For the worlds we can reach, see Beyond Mars.

Take the free test

Sources